skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Last night (Thanksgiving Eve) I ...
Last night (Thanksgiving Eve) I placed a takeout order over the phone for my family of 6. We were quoted an hour wait, which I thought was an overestimate.

I arrived about 15 minute early, hoping my order would be ready. I was told the order would be done in 15 minutes, at the hour wait I was originally provided.

The
... read more
Danielle Y. via yelp.com - Nov 26, 2020
Great Post-Hike Meal
I found Brothers on Trip Advisor when looking for a place to eat after a hike in Storm King. I'm so glad I did! We both had the brisket sandwiches and agreed it was amazing. The cornbread was really good too. Service was excellent. For...covid concerns, the tables were spaced out properly indoors, and all staff wore masks (as did cu ... read more
bdfenwick via tripadvisor.com - Nov 22, 2020
This is such an awesome spot for ...
This is such an awesome spot for authentic, flavorful BBQ! The restaurant is cozy and tables are well spaced out. Temperatures are taken at the door. The menu has something for everyone. The complimentary cornbread is incredible! Highly recommend their wings (I tried their garlic ones). The waitress raved about the different types of ... read more
Caitlin C. via yelp.com - Nov 21, 2020
Amazing barbecue food. The ribs ...
Amazing barbecue food. The ribs were delicious and loved the Caesar salad. Definitely will be coming back ... read more
Natalia A. via yelp.com - Nov 21, 2020
Cozy place for great food with ...
Cozy place for great food with affordable price!

We found this place on Yelp and Google on our way from Storm King Art Center trip. Since they didn't take a reservation, we just walked in but we were able to get a table right away. (It was around 2:30-3pm on Saturday)

Staff members were very friendly and made sure of ou
... read more
Dain S. via yelp.com - Nov 16, 2020
The pull pork was amazing. Just enough for dinner and lunch For tomorrow lol #donttouchmyplate
The pull pork was amazing. Just enough for dinner and lunch For tomorrow lol #donttouchmyplate ... read more
D Norma Green via facebook.com - Nov 14, 2020
food was delicious and service was great
food was delicious and service was great ... read more
Valerie Ruffin via facebook.com - Nov 8, 2020
Great food, really tasty in house ...
Great food, really tasty in house BBQ sauce, fair with cornbread portions.

ONE Complaint: At the time of this writing: they don't have mashed potatoes on the menu! I will not remove a star for this, however I want hot mashed potatoes with my meat.
NOT potato salad, or baked potato, I want hot buttery mashed potatoes to soak
... read more
Lev T. via yelp.com - Nov 2, 2020
Off the charts ! The best barbecue ...
Off the charts ! The best barbecue place in. nY servings are large and more than enough ! Service is excellent!
Tony T. via yelp.com - Oct 30, 2020
Top class BBQ and service. Couldn't ...
Top class BBQ and service. Couldn't have asked for a better time after walking around Storm King for hours. Highly recommended!
John S. via yelp.com - Oct 30, 2020
10 stars
Wow! Today was a very special day for my family. We adopted our foster son! His favorite place is Brothers and let me tell you, they treated him like a king! Not only is the food awesome and delicious but everyone who works there is...incredibly nice. He had the opportunity to meet two of the Brothers and he was so excited! They made ... read more
Stacialeep via tripadvisor.com - Oct 30, 2020
We went to Brothers on a hiking ...
We went to Brothers on a hiking trip upstate this weekend. Overall I enjoyed Brothers, it was a homey BBQ spot with great music choices! The staff was very friendly and I liked that they would take your number and text you in your car when the table was ready so you weren't waiting around with everyone. We started with an order of ma ... read more
Rebecca M. via yelp.com - Oct 26, 2020
amazing juicy burgers, fries are great. I remember back in the day I went there n amazing ribs n al
amazing juicy burgers, fries are great. I remember back in the day I went there n amazing ribs n all. down right awesome food. filled me up n I'm a big guy, I couldn't eat it all. I'm glad u 3 made awesome coming place. from 1 of ur old friend Vern ... read more
Vern Couser via facebook.com - Oct 24, 2020
Everything was good. They need to work on the drinks though... mohito had some mint syrup instead o
Everything was good. They need to work on the drinks though... mohito had some mint syrup instead of mint leaves Then the gin and tonic too wasn’t made right but the food is great ... read more
Troy Davey via facebook.com - Oct 18, 2020
I love their food. Great customer ...
I love their food. Great customer service too. You definitely will not regret eating here. They had live music when we ate there before COVID happened.
Aj P. via yelp.com - Oct 14, 2020
We were a party of 4 and we all ordered something different. We shared it all. Every appetizer a
We were a party of 4 and we all ordered something different. We shared it all. Every appetizer and every meal was delicious. The mac 'n cheese was declared the best we've ever eaten at a restaurant! This was our 4th or 5th barbecue restaurant together and our favorite by far! We're looking forward to trying the rest of the menu.
Ron Paust via facebook.com - Oct 11, 2020
First time here..the food was excellent as was the service!!!
First time here..the food was excellent as was the service!!!
Bill Sivillo via facebook.com - Oct 10, 2020
The food at this place is extremely ...
The food at this place is extremely awesome I couldn't say anything negative about this place the atmospheres friendly very personal portions of decent and the price wasn't that bad having acid reflux I thought it wouldn't be good for me went to bed and had no episode i-will-be-back Brothers ... read more
Chris S. via yelp.com - Oct 10, 2020
After a long day of looking at ...
After a long day of looking at beautiful sculptures at StormKing this is the icing on the cake. Safe during covid times. Highly recommend the corn bread and brisket. If you sit outside there might be 2 bees that come to try and eat your bbq.
Lizette A. via yelp.com - Oct 8, 2020
The brisket was fork-tender and literally melted in my mouth. The sides were homemade and outstandi
The brisket was fork-tender and literally melted in my mouth. The sides were homemade and outstanding!
Jerry Whittle via facebook.com - Oct 4, 2020
the Brisket was so tender it melted in your mouth. the smoked slab bacon appetizer was also AMAZI
the Brisket was so tender it melted in your mouth. the smoked slab bacon appetizer was also AMAZING.
Spyda Ryder via facebook.com - Oct 4, 2020
Best pulled pork and mac and cheese.
Best pulled pork and mac and cheese.
Laurie Ann Whittle via facebook.com - Oct 4, 2020
absolutely love brothers BBQ!! I LOVE....LOVE....LOVE relaxing there after a long week. the bartend
absolutely love brothers BBQ!! I LOVE....LOVE....LOVE relaxing there after a long week. the bartenders and wait staff are absolutely fantastic!!
Shelva Thomas via facebook.com - Oct 3, 2020
This place always knocks it out ...
This place always knocks it out of the park. Super clean and friendly staff all around. Food is perfect every time regardless of what we order. Can't wait for more tables to be brought in and hopefully live music will follow. I wish they had Wi-Fi but I'm willing to give up scrolling through my phone in order to enjoy a good meal wit ... read more
Michael H. via yelp.com - Sep 25, 2020
Excellent bbq fair price. Really ...
Excellent bbq fair price. Really enjoyed it.
Corn bread is fantastic.
One issue. I ordered a half tray of corn bread and when I picked it up I was advised that they would no longer sell half sheets.  This doesn't make any sense. That have the packaging to sell half sheets.   If not for them offering the half sheet I wouldn't
... read more
John N. via yelp.com - Sep 23, 2020
I visit this superb restaurant every couple of days because I love the good air that is characterizes this place. The personel is exceptionally attentive and experienced. The service is awfully rapid. Needless to say, the food they cook is great. I came many times and I was never disappointed. The rate is honest. I highly suggest thi ... read more
Leonard Sutton via google.com - Sep 22, 2020
The food was amazing. Staff friendly. I will be back and I will bring friends.
The food was amazing. Staff friendly. I will be back and I will bring friends.
Petrina Jackson via facebook.com - Sep 20, 2020
The bbq is delicious and the service ...
The bbq is delicious and the service is just as good. They were very good about making us feel safe and keeping everyone at a good distance. One of my favorite things we ordered were the collard greens  Would definitely go back.
Sharlene C. via yelp.com - Sep 13, 2020
Great service. Food came to us hot, which is really big for me. Food was very good.
Great service. Food came to us hot, which is really big for me. Food was very good.
Paula Poloniak Kammarada via facebook.com - Sep 12, 2020
First time at the restaurant. Food was delicious portions great. Staff was very pleasant and atten
First time at the restaurant. Food was delicious portions great. Staff was very pleasant and attentive! Ordered the 2 meat platter.... got a 3rd side extra.
Cheryl Hunter-Grant via facebook.com - Sep 6, 2020
Good good but we ordered two collard ...
Good good but we ordered two collard greens and got one collard and one green beans which we did not order. My grandson who likes collard greens was disappointed.
Diana J. via yelp.com - Sep 5, 2020
BBQ SAUCE IS AWESOME. FOOD WAS ...
BBQ SAUCE IS AWESOME. FOOD WAS GREAT. DROVE ALL THE WAY FROM QUEENS,NY. Definitely worth the drive. Great atmosphere. Can't wait till they can fully open n are able to have the live music back. Smoked meats were also phenomenal. Staff n customer service was great.
M Primus P. via yelp.com - Sep 4, 2020
I had the pleasure of ordering from your restaurant tonight on my way home from a work event. I was
I had the pleasure of ordering from your restaurant tonight on my way home from a work event. I was hesitant because I arrived at 7:37pm (and you close at 8). Your staff approached my vehicle as soon as I got there and explained the ordering process and made it so easy. Your staff tonight was so very impressive. So professional and q ... read more
Becky Mulvey Dominguez via facebook.com - Aug 31, 2020
Great barbecue! My family loves ...
Great barbecue! My family loves the eat like a king meal! Always ready on time for curbside pickup and great service to the car!
Allison R. via yelp.com - Aug 27, 2020
This was a great lunch. The wait staff was very nice. The food was amazing.I recommend the Southe
This was a great lunch. The wait staff was very nice. The food was amazing. I recommend the Southern Fried Pickles, and the pulled pork. We will definitely be returning.
Mike WC Simpson-Pisano via facebook.com - Aug 15, 2020
Love the brisket actually everything ...
Love the brisket actually everything is great here along with staff
Wish they would get the smoked Bacon back
... read more
Al G. via yelp.com - Aug 15, 2020
By far the best BBQ place in the ...
By far the best BBQ place in the Orange County and maybe NY in general. The staff is really great, the decor is welcoming and clean, the food is absolutely amazing. Try the pulled pork!
Michael S. via yelp.com - Aug 15, 2020
dinner tonight was AMAZING! pickup was easy and so was ordering
dinner tonight was AMAZING! pickup was easy and so was ordering ... read more
Diane Tarabar Troeller via facebook.com - Aug 14, 2020
was there tonight and the food was amazing. had the hungry helper appetizer was was phenomenal and
was there tonight and the food was amazing. had the hungry helper appetizer was was phenomenal and then 3 of us shared the eat like a king which had ribs, chicken, brisket, and pulled pork and let me tell u I am a certified bbq judge and this was one of the best bbq meals I have had in a long time.
Brian Pincus via facebook.com - Aug 14, 2020
Delicious bbq and very thoughtful wait servers
Delicious bbq and very thoughtful wait servers ... read more
Mary Blaney Impellizeri via facebook.com - Aug 8, 2020
Great and friendly service
Great and friendly service ... read more
David Snell via facebook.com - Aug 7, 2020
We came from New Haven CT... the food was outstanding and the service was impeccable.... you guys r
We came from New Haven CT... the food was outstanding and the service was impeccable.... you guys rock & you definitely get 5 stars from us... see you soon 🤞🏼 ... read more
Rebecca Torres via facebook.com - Jul 26, 2020
Great food and COVID safe! Must ...
Great food and COVID safe! Must get brisket and wings! Friendly service beats barnstormer and billy joes for best BBQ in the area ... read more
Joshua M. via yelp.com - Jul 20, 2020
These Brothers have put their foot ...
These Brothers have put their foot in it! I know that they are really drawing in folks fro around the area. They offer several different styles of BBQ to choose from and they are all amazing. They have found a niche that the local foodies can enjoy. I'm hoping to have them cater for me at least 1 time every season. They are pricey, b ... read more
Lionel D. via yelp.com - Jul 17, 2020
Food is alway delicious and the service is outstanding! Corn bread is so good but you have to try t
Food is alway delicious and the service is outstanding! Corn bread is so good but you have to try the Ribs and the bacon wrapped sausage.
Jenny Lites via facebook.com - Jul 12, 2020
We were traveling through the area ...
We were traveling through the area and stopped here for lunch. The pulled pork was great and the potato salad and cole slaw were fresh and delicious. The kids had chicken and Mac and cheese that they loved. Our waiter Dennis was great, he was professional, personable, and very attentive. We will definitely be coming back next time we ... read more
Mike P. via yelp.com - Jul 12, 2020
Sooooo delicious...cornbread, fried chicken and Mac and cheese is on point. Must try!! Love the atm
Sooooo delicious...cornbread, fried chicken and Mac and cheese is on point. Must try!! Love the atmosphere and decor, great customer service!
Trelinda Greene via facebook.com - Jul 7, 2020
Brothers Barbecue has awesome food. The staff are awesome too.
Brothers Barbecue has awesome food. The staff are awesome too.
Dawn Roth via facebook.com - Jun 29, 2020
Best BBQ ever! Fried chicken is to die for!
Best BBQ ever! Fried chicken is to die for!
Michele Manno via facebook.com - Jun 28, 2020
Everything is amazing! Service was excellent!!
Everything is amazing! Service was excellent!!
Danease Oviatt via facebook.com - Jun 28, 2020
Never found truly great BBQ up north... until this place. Great smoked meat!
Never found truly great BBQ up north... until this place. Great smoked meat!
Stacia Passaro via facebook.com - May 13, 2020
Delicious authentic BBQ, friendly amazing staff, warm welcoming comfortable family- friendly atmosp
Delicious authentic BBQ, friendly amazing staff, warm welcoming comfortable family- friendly atmosphere, and fantastic live music on Fridays & Saturdays!!!
Jon Bates via facebook.com - May 1, 2020
Great food and service. Love the ...
Great food and service. Love the fried chicken. Service was very well done.  Came right to the car as soon as you pull in so there was no confusion. Thank you Brothers bbq!
Rosemarie S. via yelp.com - Apr 30, 2020
I recommend Brothers Barbecue Restaraunt, because the food is awesome, tasteful, no matter what mea
I recommend Brothers Barbecue Restaraunt, because the food is awesome, tasteful, no matter what meal you order the customer will come back for more. The wings and fried chicken can’t forget the pulled pork is tasty especially the barbecue sauce mmm. The Brothers and the staff are very friendly and will accommodate their customers t ... read more
Salina Walker via facebook.com - Apr 21, 2020
Brothers BBQ has really pivoted to feed us all with soul food safely and efficiently as we shelter
Brothers BBQ has really pivoted to feed us all with soul food safely and efficiently as we shelter in place! Brilliant!
Will Juntunen via facebook.com - Apr 20, 2020
Ordered through GrubHub, based on calling the phone number, thirty minutes later, while I am sittin
Ordered through GrubHub, based on calling the phone number, thirty minutes later, while I am sitting in the parking lot, I get a text that the order was cancelled, needless to say I was furious. Spoke with the chef who apologized and filled the order for us. I would make the suggestion that you have an alternate greeting for when y ... read more
April Dawn Riley via facebook.com - Apr 12, 2020
Absolutely delicious 😋 and they have a great set up to keep us all safe with curb side pick up.
Absolutely delicious 😋 and they have a great set up to keep us all safe with curb side pick up.
Laurie Owen via facebook.com - Apr 1, 2020
I have about 60 guys that are away from their families here in Montgomery working to help fill the
I have about 60 guys that are away from their families here in Montgomery working to help fill the grocery stores in the local area. My guys have been working almost 90 hours a week to ensure families have a place to shop during this Virus. And due to a last minute catering cancellation, I called Brothers Barbecue and they came throu ... read more
Chase Thompson via facebook.com - Mar 29, 2020
with this crazy pandemic going on we are so glad Brothers offers curb side delivery , we ordered th
with this crazy pandemic going on we are so glad Brothers offers curb side delivery , we ordered the chicken sandwich with cole slaw, mac and cheese baked beans ! with the side of brothers sauce .The food was absolutely amazing ..The chicken sandwich is fantastic ... read more
Tara Lynn via facebook.com - Mar 28, 2020
I don't even know what to say....it is that good
I don't even know what to say....it is that good ... read more
Nyree Collins via facebook.com - Mar 14, 2020
This little gem in Orange County ...
This little gem in Orange County ( new Windsor) is worth the stop. The outside may not look like much but the inside is very nice with a bar and fireplace the food is good and the people are warm and don't forget that cornbread so delicious  
Sorry Guys i forgot to take pictures
... read more
Shaunte W. via yelp.com - Mar 14, 2020
Absolutely the best barbecue I've ...
Absolutely the best barbecue I've ever eaten. The wings are to die for and they have a fried shrimp dinner that is better than the shrimp you would get at a good seafood restaurant. Do not hesitate to try this place. It may not look like fine dining, but the dining is real fine!
Jimbo C. via yelp.com - Mar 8, 2020
very friendly staff and great selection of sides and main dishes
very friendly staff and great selection of sides and main dishes ... read more
Mike Hicks via facebook.com - Mar 8, 2020
Hands down the best BBQ we've had ...
Hands down the best BBQ we've had in this area and we've been looking for a good place!  Family friendly and good live music. A big too bright inside (my idea of a BBQ blues joint is a little dimmer) but that is the only downside.
Kusemono M. via yelp.com - Mar 7, 2020
Great bbq and family friendly...
Great bbq and family friendly...
Debbie Shea-Schiraldi via facebook.com - Mar 7, 2020
SO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Michael Tillotson via facebook.com - Mar 6, 2020
Great pizza ... read more
Matt F via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
Stocking up on the absolute best bbq sauce! Awesome customer service and amazing food!
Stocking up on the absolute best bbq sauce! Awesome customer service and amazing food!
Joe Thompson via facebook.com - Mar 2, 2020
Great food! Try the Whiskey Bread pudding dessert!!
Great food! Try the Whiskey Bread pudding dessert!!
Betsy Lansdell Sharo via facebook.com - Feb 27, 2020
The food was good large portions. I decided to go with apps versus a meal, I order 3 apps WAYYY too
The food was good large portions. I decided to go with apps versus a meal, I order 3 apps WAYYY too much for 1. I enjoyed it the staff was friendly and nice atmosphere. My only issue the music was alittle down it was the blues and it made me alittle blue (did you see what I did there lol) Very enjoyable ... read more
Shawn C. Hobson via facebook.com - Feb 23, 2020
I hate pickles but by some kitchen ...
I hate pickles but by some kitchen magic that is going on at Brothers, I would eat a bucket of theirs.  They are monumental!  Every time we have been here, we've been so pleased.  If you leave hungry, it's your own fault!  The portions are huge!  Tip:  when ordering the loaded fries, bring 2 friends!
Jill L. via yelp.com - Feb 23, 2020
Great food, large portions, friendly wait staff
Great food, large portions, friendly wait staff ... read more
Shonna Nicole via facebook.com - Feb 23, 2020
Everything is delicious.  Been ...
Everything is delicious.  Been going for years and they are the real deal.  Fantastic bbq, wings, fried chicken I could go on and on.
Patricia B. via yelp.com - Feb 22, 2020
Not being from the area, my boyfriend ...
Not being from the area, my boyfriend and I found Brothers from a google search and we're glad we did. The wait time was not long and the atmosphere was great. They had live music that evening which was fun. The food was delicious! I had the fried chicken with mac and cheese and candied yams which was soooo good! My boyfriend ordered ... read more
Maria R. via yelp.com - Feb 21, 2020
Great food great great service
Great food great great service ... read more
Joseph Melville via facebook.com - Feb 21, 2020
I just had the Bro Ribber and it was outstanding!
I just had the Bro Ribber and it was outstanding!
Ian Jason Genao via facebook.com - Feb 19, 2020
A great place to dine and relax - great staff and food
A great place to dine and relax - great staff and food ... read more
Joseph Volkmer via facebook.com - Feb 18, 2020
We were hungry and they understood exactly what we needed! Fix your meat craving no doubt...
We were hungry and they understood exactly what we needed! Fix your meat craving no doubt...
Chamille Thayer via facebook.com - Feb 16, 2020
Best BBQ around
Brothers BBQ is a must go place. Great selections of real BBQ done right. Unbeatable service and always a great experience. Never had a bad meal.
Bbqman1967 via tripadvisor.com - Feb 11, 2020
Great food and service! The brisket is so, so tender!
Great food and service! The brisket is so, so tender!
Michelle Pomarico via facebook.com - Feb 9, 2020
food was excellent and a good portion.waitress was great, timed the service and was attentive to d
food was excellent and a good portion. waitress was great, timed the service and was attentive to drink refills.
Al Pfingstl via facebook.com - Feb 8, 2020
Great 👍🏻 family place. Service was great.
Great 👍🏻 family place. Service was great.
Laura Garry via facebook.com - Feb 8, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire